Видео

The caste system is no longer regarded as a Hindu creation. It was created by economic necessity and by colonialism. It is also peacticed by christians and muslims, so it is not exclusive to Hinduism

Excellent discussion. Thank you.

The origins of this politicization are from the colonial era onwards.

You people adding a on every historical things of india what t hell

Oh pleeeease have the book of mormon and the book of Abraham in here!!!

This video is retar*** or politicaly correct mentally challenged. The corners of the pyramid aren’t perfectly square because there are 8 sides. They also keep using term theoretical a lot while referring to palms and fingers as the go to for accurate angles. We truly live in a clown world. How anyone watches this video and agrees confirms how clueless and ignorant people are these days. Just agree with whatever your school books says kids. People like Randal come with hard facts. People like this come with no research they have done themselves. CLOWNS!

Nobody here truly knows anything about history NO ONE DOES everybody just wants to be the smartest person in the room

I enjoy your videos, very much; they combine the best aspects of documentaries produced by film production companies (proffesional quality photography and sound) and the casualness of home movies, all the while being interesting and informative. There is something about which I am curious; I will state, up front, that I ask this, not to start a RUclips comments brawl. I have noticed a shift in the pronounciation of the word "agora," in the past few years and was wondering where the change comes from; these shifts are a part of language progression, which is why we do not speak like Goeffrey Chaucer today. This was even the basis for a song in a classic movie, Ginger Rogers\ Fred Astaire's "Let's Call the Whole Thing Off!" ("You Say tomato...") So, can you enlighten me as to the shift; new scholarship in linguistics or an influencial scholar, such as yourself or Dr. Bettany Hughes using the pronounciation. Thank you for this video and I look forward to your future videos.😊

The Aryans migrated to India, not invaded. We all.came from Africa and "migrated" to other areas of the world

The “bag” is a container for blood which theses “gods” drank to keep physical form. They had to continually drink from them or they would become ethereal again which was their original form.

You should make another video titled "What Graham Hancock Gets RIGHT about Flood Myths and it should just be 10 minutes of black screen.

And the men who politicized it are men like you, cut from the same cloth as you, and carrying the same biases as you. Keep up the noble work of defending corrupt academicians while you lap up that YT revenue.

Thanks Dr. And thanks, "MyHeritage", I like that, I'll definitely look into that. - Yes, that's not Phoenician. I know Phoenician. I guess back then it would fool people. And ouch, now people would do a more convincing job. I'm still lost trying to find clues in ancient Nubian script. So similar to Egyptian and other Semitic scripts of that era, but indecipherable. Maybe AI will steal our human thunder and solve it for us. Though is science science if we don't solve the puzzles? :/ - You may think I'm just using 20-20 hindsight, but that Darius pottery script didn't look correct either. Both have the characters spaced oddly too far apart. Don't discount this. Every script I've seen, or the majority seem squished together. Always they are running out of room or didn't think through how much space they had per number of characters. I've seen (in newer script) where a B and W are so close you think it's an M character. Or the K character with W making an M character.

I'm watching all of your videos. You ROCK. You would be a good VP.

You are mostly very right . Especially at the point that "what you do now counts , not your long past ancestors" . Of course you stated too many things and some may be arguable . But I will stay at one point that I think you overlooked . It's about cherry picking . One can cherry pick pieces to his interest and present a false interpretation of facts . But one can also "cherry" let out pieces so it will be again false .

Ashokanzi are almost purely European. They have no more Levantine DNA than Italians .

If ancestral residence gives precedence for territorial claim, then all the lands of North and South America need to return governorship to the indigenous people. 34:05 Good luck convincing the non-indigenous to turn the land ownership over.

Truth hurts?

@world of antiquity. Can you please let us know how long have you lived in India, How many Indian languages you know, and whether you are conversant with customs and traditions including cuisine and food habits? Have you made a systematic study of ancient Indian shastras on language, literature, astronomy, medicine, mathematics, etc? If you have made this video without having a deeper understanding of all factors stated above, then whatever you said in the video does not hold good and it's just superficially covering your intentions which of course you are not explicit. No Indian needs extensive research papers done by so-called scholars on India who are not native to understand our Indian heritage. Everyone knows that in India the education imparted in the existing system for the past 150 years was designed by the British and its sole purpose was to subjugate Indians. Just imagine how many generations have been brainwashed with this systematic plan of Westerners. Now you ask us to counter or challenge any argument stated in the video rather than the questioning video creator's understanding of India. So we may get lost in the quagmire of research papers looking into microscopic detail forgetting the intra-disciplinary approach. You start the video by acknowledging the contribution of Indians in the fields of Sciences of astronomy, math, medicine, and so on then you start confusing us with different in migration and out-migration theories of the Indian subcontinent diluting the underlying factor of continuity of Indian civilization. You start talking about the Caste system which of course is an alien concept and is used in Government parlance and for Political mileage to compromise the unity and integrity of India.

30:06 does "no information" about Atlantis exist? What a condescending jerk. Last I checked, the Richat Structure constitutes not only "evidence," but proof. Read the Algonquin flood history and stop relying on the appeal to skepticism. 32:19 oh, you speak out both sides of your mouth.

This is the problem with this conspiracy, they take something interesting linguistics, notice something doesn't fit how our language organizes/labels color and then assumes they didn't see color.

Just Awesome

Ya dont know how they did it and still trying to convince the Incas did it. They did not have the tools to cut the harder stones. We could not do this work today.

Wow. Comments demonstrate the some people passionately want to feel superior because of their supposed ancient ancestors. Labrador Retreivers come in black, brown and yellow. They're all dogs, and all Labradors whatever their color. If you want to be proud, be proud of YOUR OWN character and accomplishments.

Part of the motivation is short term personal gains, they can enrich themselves or feel powerful at the expense of peope they do not care about. I guess this is why Trump wants to cut the education budget in half, dumming people down so fake history and ideological fantasies can prevail.

Awesome video ❤ My opinion man was always human, not ape like. Scientists are just unable to answer the question?, were did man come from? Atom lol. People did live in caves, which makes them cavemen 😮😊

"The Aryan invasion never happened", so I guess no one was living in India when the Aryans migrated there.

Damn America, your political culture wars are ruining everything in my country!

Mechanisms like this do not just appear overnight. There must have been a gradual learning process in the creation of the materials, the tools and the function before this mechanism was actually built. For example, when the automobile was first invented, it took over 100 years to get from a Model T to where we are today, so it is logical that there was probably a century or 2 of mechanisms being built and refined before this one was built.

Why do you speak of Indians and Dravidians as two separate people?

Goa'uld of course.

History is an academic discipline, historians should be completely impartial

There is nothing wrong about respecting, honoring or being proud of your ancestors, just don't use them as a justification to be a bad person

Really great talk as usual

If you read vedas you go 2000 to 3000 BCE if you know Jyotishashasra you go 6000 to 8000 BCE. Nobody knows the truth but one thing amaze me that from every nation at that time was in the search of India that is Bharat. 🙏

Don't manipulate Vyasa ( the group of sages) wrote the vedas. ( Oral collections came in the time of invasion ) 🙏

Enjoyed watching your video. Plenty of valid points. Archaeology isn't just one big club, resistant to change. I've spent many hours watching Graham Hancock vids. Bottom line for me is that these vids are interesting. I'm not emotionally invested either way. Like with 'Ancient Aliens'. It's great entertainment. Having said that, it seems pretty obvious to me that the ancient America's were filled by multiple pathways of migration. Not just thru Alaska. But then, who cares. It doesn't change my life.

Would you please consider running for public office? You have crystal clear common sense, you are not partisan, you are very calm and very, very eloquent. Our country at this point has a great need of these qualities in its leaders.

you forgot about how people use ancient history to make argurment that other nation don't exist.

These mofos whitewash EVERYTHING!!!!!!

'Race and identity do hold significance as social constructs'. This is itself an ideologically informed assertion.

Imagine spending days, if not weeks, waking up every morning in the hot Egyptian sun, affixing your piece of granite to a wheel with clay or pitch, and progressively chipping and grinding away at your work piece to create your magnum opus: the closest to perfectly even granite drinking vessel you've ever been able to produce. All for your hard work to be attributed to magic ancient aliens with machines 6000 years later

Bingo!

Foerster is a "Gringo tour guide" according to some locals here in the Sacred Valley. I was invited to Cusco by Foerster in 2012. He had a case of Behind the Monitor bravery when I asked him a question and he told me if I wanted the answer to that come here and find that answer yourself. I was here 3 months later, and I haven't seen him yet. If you want to meet him face to face, I guess you have to pay for one of his tours.... I did find the answers to many questions only to find more questions without answers. yet

If we weren't so predictable about interrogating and vivisecting ambassadors from other planets and dimensions, maybe someone would share information about the world-spanning civilizations on Earth in the last half-billion years, and the weapons or natural cataclysms that wiped away every iota, shadow, and squeak of evidence miles deep. Or in the Smithsonian, same thing.

I surmise that one of the original seeds of Hyperborea was rumour carried along Neolthic trade-routes of peoples far to the North (perhaps Boreal tribes?).

Remember those carving are on Hard Granite Rocks not Lime Stone

It's always been politicized. History has and always be a telling of the past to justify the actions of the current political/religions leaders. Only about 1% of people truly care about the reality of the past

Going to use this as a guide when I visit Turkey 😊